After the massive success of The Curse of the Black Pearl, it was rather obvious that Disney had a franchise on their hands. So, it was inevitable that a sequel was going to be made. Or in this case, two sequels.

Producer Jerry Bruckheimer gathered his director Gore Verbinski, his co-stars Orlando Bloom and Kiera Knightly, and of course his Oscar nominated actor Johnny Depp. The result is 2006’s Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Man’s Chest. A movie that despite being hammered by so-so reviews, went on to make over $1 billion.

Join Garrett, Matt, and Adam as they take a look at the sequel and conclude whether its bad reviews were warranted. And be sure to keep coming back as the boys will continue looking at the entire Pirates of the Caribbean franchise, all the way through 2017’s Dead Men Tell No Tales!